Quick Verdict
Choose Keeps if you want the lowest price on standard finasteride + minoxidil. They're a hair loss specialist with simple, affordable plans.
Choose Hims if you want more treatment options: oral minoxidil, topical finasteride, combination chewables, or other services (ED, skincare) alongside hair.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Keeps | Hims |
|---|---|---|
| Finasteride Price | $10/mo ✓ | $16/mo |
| Topical Minoxidil | $15/mo | $15/mo |
| Oral Minoxidil | Limited | Yes ✓ |
| Topical Finasteride | No | Yes ✓ |
| Combo Products | Basic bundle | Chewables, custom ✓ |
| Other Services | Hair only | ED, skin, weight ✓ |
| Consultation | Free | Free |
Keeps: The Budget Champion
Keeps focuses exclusively on hair loss. This specialization lets them offer the lowest prices on standard treatments. If you just want finasteride and/or topical minoxidil at the best price, Keeps wins.
Best For:
- ✓ Budget-conscious guys
- ✓ Those who just want standard finasteride + minoxidil
- ✓ First-time hair loss treatment
Limitations:
- ✗ Limited oral minoxidil availability
- ✗ No topical finasteride
- ✗ Hair only — no ED or other services
Hims: The Options Leader
Hims offers more treatment variations than anyone else. If standard finasteride isn't right for you (side effect concerns, topical didn't work), Hims has alternatives.
Best For:
- ✓ Guys who want oral minoxidil (the game-changer)
- ✓ Those worried about finasteride side effects (topical option)
- ✓ Anyone who also needs ED treatment
- ✓ Preference for combo chewables
Limitations:
- ✗ Slightly higher base pricing
- ✗ More upselling in the experience
The Oral Minoxidil Factor
This is the key differentiator. Oral minoxidil is the biggest advancement in hair loss treatment in years. It works even when topical minoxidil fails (30-40% of men).
Hims offers oral minoxidil readily. Keeps has limited availability. If you've tried topical without results, or just want the convenience of a daily pill instead of twice-daily liquid, Hims is the better choice.
Final Recommendation
Choose Keeps If:
- • You want the lowest price
- • Standard finasteride + minoxidil is fine
- • You only need hair treatment
Choose Hims If:
- • You want oral minoxidil
- • You prefer topical finasteride
- • You also need ED treatment