Quick Verdict
Choose BlueChew if you specifically want chewable tablets in the most discreet packaging (mint tin). Simple subscription, chewable-only.
Choose Hims if you want more options: pills + chewables, combo products, or additional services (hair, weight loss).
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | BlueChew | Hims |
|---|---|---|
| Format | Chewables only | Pills + chewables |
| Packaging | Discreet tin ✓ | Standard bottle |
| Medications | Sildenafil, tadalafil, vardenafil | Same + combos ✓ |
| Starting Price | $20/mo (6 tabs) | $2/dose ✓ |
| Other Services | ED only | Hair, weight, etc ✓ |
| Subscription | Required | Flexible |
When to Choose BlueChew
- ✓ You specifically want chewables (no water needed)
- ✓ Discreet tin packaging matters to you
- ✓ Simple subscription model appeals to you
- ✓ You want vardenafil (Levitra) option
- ✓ You only need ED treatment
When to Choose Hims
- ✓ You want Hard Mints (sildenafil + tadalafil combo)
- ✓ You prefer traditional pills or want options
- ✓ You also need hair or weight loss treatment
- ✓ You want the cheapest possible generic pricing
- ✓ You prefer a polished app experience
Pricing Breakdown
BlueChew Plans
- Active: $20/mo (6 chewables)
- Busy: $30/mo (10 chewables)
- Popular: $40/mo (14 chewables)
- Pro: $50+/mo (17+ chewables)
Hims Pricing
- Generic sildenafil: $2-4/dose
- Generic tadalafil: $4-6/dose
- Hard Mints: $8-10/dose
- Daily tadalafil: $8-12/mo
Our Recommendation
Hims wins for most guys due to more options and better pricing flexibility. But if you specifically love the chewable format and discreet tin, BlueChew is excellent.